Title: Nounish Friends - Stage 2

Proposer: nouncil.eth

Block: 15535995

Link: https://nouns.wtf/vote/141

Request:

Result: DEFEATED

• FOR - 78 votes, 19 voters
• AGAINST - 88 votes, 8 voters
• ABSTAIN - 0 votes, 0 voters

TL;DR

• First time seeing this many well thought-out on-chain reasons - great for governance
• Lots of different opposition reasons; from the aesthetics, to distribution specifics, to funding amount.
• Very close and contentious proposal - a couple voters could flip the result if re-submitted with some parameters changed
• Lots of discussion in Discord - see below

Martin’s Take

This is a really interesting proposal and outcome. The builder has been funded before (prop #72) and is active in the community via Nouncil, which is always helpful. However, the specifics around the end deliverables and the aesthetics seem to have led to its rejection. While the product itself is cool, I think the lack of clarity around distribution hurt it. A clearer focus on distribution as well as chatting with a few voters could definitely help this prop pass if re-submitted.